Support Torah
Recordings

Pride in Our Traditions: Answering the Mockers of the Generation

Classes, Toldos – Pride in Our Traditions: Answering the Mockers of the Generation

גאווה במסורת: מענה לליצני הדור

Pride in Our Traditions: Answering the Mockers of the Generation

This shiur asks why the Torah repeats that Avraham fathered Yitzchak and why Rashi says it answers the mockers of the generation. It teaches not to hide our practices out of fear of ridicule, and to raise our children with pride in the mesorah.
Prev Search
0:00 0:00
Next

1. Navigating Unfamiliar Jewish Practices

Many times, we might feel uncomfortable performing certain mitzvos or following specific customs because others may look at us strangely. People who are not familiar with Judaism, or even those within the Jewish community who do not observe halachah—Jewish law, might not understand why we do what we do. This can be especially true for those who are meticulous in their observance, such as following the ways of Chabad or the teachings instituted by the Rebbe. Others may question why these details are so important, and sometimes it feels like our practices are misunderstood or even mocked.

2. Celebrating Tradition: A Personal Example

A family had the great privilege to bring their youngest son into cheder—Jewish elementary school. I witnessed how they did it [UNCLEAR: medalla pitchefkes]—with all the little details as prescribed by tradition. Observing their careful attention to every aspect of the minhagim brought to mind how some people might see these customs as strange or excessive. Yet, these details are deeply meaningful and connect us to generations past.

3. The Redundancy in the Parsha’s Opening Verses

Tying this into Parshas Toldos, right at the beginning it says: “These are the children of Yitzchak, son of Avraham.” If you say Yitzchak is the son of Avraham, it’s clear who his father is. Yet, the verse continues: “Avraham gave birth to Yitzchak” (Bereishis 25:19). This seems redundant—if we know Yitzchak is Avraham’s son, why does the Torah need to spell it out again? Rashi addresses this question in his first comment on the parsha.

4. Rashi’s Explanations: Addressing Doubt and Mockery

Rashi offers two explanations. First, he notes that only after Avram became Avraham—following Hashem’s promise and name change—was he able to have children. Before that, as Avram, he could not have children. The second explanation is particularly interesting: Rashi says that because there were Leitzanei Hador—the mockers of that generation—who claimed that Sarah became pregnant not from Avraham but from Avimelech (since Sarah was taken into Avimelech’s house), Hashem made Yitzchak look exactly like Avraham. This way, when people saw Yitzchak ben Avraham, there was visible evidence that he was truly Avraham’s son.

5. The Torah’s Response to Mockers: A Deeper Question

This Rashi is surprising for several reasons. First, why does the Torah need to respond specifically to the mockers? If there was genuine doubt among people about Yitzchak’s parentage due to Sarah’s long period of infertility and her time in Avimelech’s house, wouldn’t it make sense for Hashem to address everyone’s concerns? Yet Rashi emphasizes that it was only for the Leitzanei Hador, those who would make fun regardless of evidence. Even after Hashem made Yitzchak resemble Avraham so closely, these mockers would likely continue making fun—they weren’t interested in truth but in ridicule.

6. Is Resemblance Really a Miracle?

Another question arises: Is it really such a miracle for a child to look like a parent? That seems natural—often you can tell a child belongs to their parent without any special sign or DNA test. So why does Hashem need to intervene here? Perhaps this wasn’t about performing an outstanding miracle but rather about reinforcing a message.

7. The Lesson: Pride in Our Traditions

Reflecting on all this leads back to our opening discussion about being proud of our traditions even when others don’t understand them. The Torah isn’t trying to convince those who will always mock; rather, it encourages us not to hide our beliefs or practices out of fear of ridicule or misunderstanding. By stating “Yitzchak ben Avraham,” and emphasizing their resemblance and connection, the Torah teaches us about transmitting tradition from one generation to another—mesorah. Yitzchak doesn’t stand alone; he is part of a chain going back to Avraham.

8. Raising Children with Confidence and Faith

When we talk about Toldos—children and generations—it is especially important not to hide who we are or what we stand for when educating our children. We should be proud Jews and proud Chassidim, openly following our traditions without apology or minimization. When we do so with confidence and faithfulness, others will eventually recognize and respect our authenticity. May Hashem grant us all much nachas from our children and help us raise them with pride in their heritage as true “Yitzchak ben Avraham.”
Leave Feedback