Support Torah
Recordings

Who was punished by the flood

Classes, Noach – Who was punished by the flood

מי נענש במבול ותכלית המבול העמוקה

Who Was Punished by the Flood and the Deeper Purpose of the Mabul

This shiur explores who was punished in the flood of Noach, why Noach's children were spared, and how Chassidus views the mabul as both punishment and cleansing. It discusses Rashi's insights, exceptions to individual punishment, earlier warnings, and the hopeful transition to Avraham.
Prev Search
0:00 0:00
Next

1. The Purpose of the Flood: Punishment or Cleansing?

The portion of Noach deals with the flood, the mabul—the deluge that God brought upon the world. While it is often viewed as a punishment for the sins and corruption of humanity, Chassidic insight teaches that it was also a cleansing process. The evil had become so saturated in the world, even absorbed into the ground itself, that only a thorough purification could remove it. The floodwaters acted as a kind of mikvah—a ritual bath—cleansing and renewing creation.

2. Rashi’s Insights on Noach’s Children and Timing

Rashi points out several unusual details leading up to the mabul. One notable point is that Noach had his children at age 500, whereas others in his generation had their first recorded child around age 100. The Torah mentions that people had sons and daughters, but only records the firstborn at a certain age. With Noach, all his children were born when he was 500 years old. Rashi explains this was because God had already decreed that if people did not repent, He would bring the flood. In those days, punishment was withheld until a person reached 100 years old; before then, one was considered a minor and not fully responsible for their actions. God arranged for Noach’s children to be under 100 when the flood came so they would be spared from punishment and not perish in the flood, sparing Noach from additional pain.

3. Questions About Who Was Punished

This explanation raises questions: What about all other people who were under 100 at the time? If being underage protected Noach’s children, why didn’t it protect others? Furthermore, all animals and living things on dry land perished as well, indicating there was more involved than just individual sin or responsibility by age. Even Noach’s children would not have been spared if they were of age for punishment.

4. The 120-Year Grace Period

The decree regarding the flood actually began earlier. At the end of Parshas Bereishis (Bereishis 6:3), God says man’s years will be 120 years. Rashi explains this refers not to human lifespan but to a grace period: God gave humanity 120 years to repent before bringing judgment. During this time, Noach built the teivah—the ark—which took exactly those 120 years to complete. This extended period served as an opportunity for everyone to improve their ways, but ultimately only Noach responded.

5. Responsibility for Sin: Children and Exceptions

Generally, Torah law teaches that each person is punished only for their own sins—“everybody dies for his own sin” (Devarim 24:16). For example, testimony from a son against his father or vice versa is not accepted; each stands on their own merits or faults. However, there are exceptions where even small children are punished along with adults—such as in cases like ir hanidachas—a city led astray—or by Korach’s rebellion where Rashi notes even children were swallowed up due to the severity of machlokes—discord. Small children are sometimes considered almost possessions of their parents; thus, punishing them can serve as a penalty to their parents. In Noach’s case, since he was a tzaddik, if his children were under 100 it would have been punishing him by taking them away—so they were spared. For others: if over 100 they died for their own sins; if under 100 they perished as part of their parents’ fate.

6. Earlier Floods and Warnings Before Noach

It is less known that there was a semi-flood before Noach’s time—in the days of Enosh—a tsunami-like event that flooded one third of the world. Rashi brings this down as an earlier warning from God for people to change their ways before He brought destruction upon all creation through the full mabul. Despite these warnings, humanity did not heed them.

7. The Emotional Tone of Parshas Noach and Moving Forward

Parshas Noach is described as somewhat sad or depressing (kalamutne) due to its focus on destruction despite its cleansing aspect. This feeling can reflect our own experience after holidays like Sukkos—after joyful times with family and celebration, returning to regular workdays can feel mildly depressing. However, this mood does not last long: at the end of Parshas Noach already Avraham is born—the first Jew—signaling hope and new beginnings after destruction. Just as we look forward after Yom Tov toward future celebrations like Chanukah (which is just about a month away), so too does Torah always provide something positive on the horizon after periods of challenge or sadness.

Leave Feedback